LD-MC | There Are No ‘Cinematic’ Games

For the Halloween season, I reviewed Shinji Mikami’s Resident Evil and Zach Cregger’s recently-released adaptation of the franchise. I greatly enjoyed both game and film, but I had one major problem with the movie. It didn’t look like RE!

Now, in visual design, the movie is almost perfect. There’s tasteful background references to game items, short of gratuitous fan-service. The design of Racoon City is correctly tight and serpentine. The zombies and their infection are wonderfully disgusting. The guns are sleek and powerful. The Umbrella laboratory is appropriately evil and sterile. So what’s the problem?

The shots!

The original games of the Resident Evil trilogy, for those unfamiliar, are famous for their fixed-camera-angle third-person point of view What this means, for those unfamiliar with the technical terms, is that, unlike in many other games, the camera does not follow your character. It is stuck somewhere else, unmoving. It might be in the corner of the room, looking up at you. It might be on a wall, looking towards a mirror you pass by. The only time this perspective updates is when Jill or Chris move out of sight, forcing a different angle to be selected, but it never updates “live”. You are stuck with what angle exists for the position you are in the room.

I loathe to spoil a game, but here is my absolute favorite example, from early on: a claustrophobic hallway with a poor view of the view forward. You creep forward and find a zombie lying dead on the floor, and then have to lose your angle on this newfound potential threat by going up the stairs. The best part? The zombie never awakens! It’s one of few floor zombies that are actually props, and not traps, but the framing of the room makes you cautious everytime you pass through.

This unique camera mechanic makes the game a bit more difficult to control, as your cardinal directions are tied to your character and not the direction of the camera; so, for example, if Jill Valentine is facing north while the camera is facing south, pressing forwards will send Jill north instead of south, which can often send new players into the waiting arms of zombies. But these “tank controls”, to use the technical term, are not wrong to be frustrating! Difficult controls makes the game scarier. The potential loss of progress and the frustration of dying adds tension, which is what survival horror is about. And, not to mention, it looks gorgeous! The off-kilter camera itself is a vehicle for horror, as shown previously, because you are never able to keep full track of a room. The shadows of trees and banisters become zombies waiting around the corner and windows you know are behind you but can no longer see are a gun pressed to your back. Its not frequent enough to make it too typical to be frightening, but the game does cash in on this tension enough to keep you terrified of your lack of control over your own senses. This, combined with the unwieldy controls, is horribly unfair and frustrating, and people who want it changed are cowards who wouldn’t know what art is if the Statue of David fell on them.

Not only does the movie fail to replicate this style of security-camera-esque angle, it actually goes in the wrong direction- there are several scenes shot in first-person, which is the perspective of RE7, 8 and segments of 9, but are far less visually interesting, especially on film. I would guess that Cregger, who is a fan of more than just the most recent entries of the series, chose this because it is far easier for an audience unfamiliar with video games to understand a first-person perspective as a reference to games- but it’s not a strong justification when this would have been very beautiful to see on the screen, a good homage to the original RE trilogy on which this film drew so heavily, and be extremely scary!

This small adaptational failure ties into a broader point I have about game design, the title of this article: the games that are so often praised for being “cinematic” or “film-like” are, very often, not at all. For the triple-A “story-driven” corporate-design titles that I so loathe, this malplaced praise is often their primary selling point. The Last of Us, Uncharted, Red Dead Redemption, etc, are designed to be alike films, but they have none of this interesting camera work in their actual games- it is entirely in non-interactable cutscenes, where, yes, there are some pretty shots- but cutscenes are ephemeral to the experience of a video game. An artistic medium holds a particular strength; for video games, that strength is not to remove all interactivity and make the player watch a movie. To tell your game’s story entirely through “cinematic” cutscenes is like a movie in which everything important that happens in the plot is described in scrolling text against an unmoving background. A game should tell its story to the player through the gameplay!

This is something my previous Ludo-Musicology article subject, Rain World, does very well; the entire arc of the protagonist is created by the design forcing the player into certain behaviors entirely naturally, as they adapt to the expectations of the world, and then pulling those expectations out from underneath them. Resident Evil, while telling its story more “traditionally” through cutscenes, still relies on the gameplay heavily to tell its story. You come to trust Barry, another STARS member, not because Jill stops and says how trustworthy he is in a cutscene, nor because the game tracks his relationship with a meter and informs you when it increases, but because he gifts you vital resources that you need to survive the mansion. You understand the evil of Umbrella Corp not from the hamfisted dialogue and poor acting of its victims in cutscenes, but because you have to fight their experiments for hours to get to those scenes.

Compare this to a previously mentioned example of AAA “storytelling”, Naughty Dog’s TLOU; while, yes, the cutscenes are very pretty, the gameplay is abysmal at conveying the story of this found-family duo. The plot progresses with an emotional moment or shocking reveal that is contained entirely within a non-interactive movie clip, then the story comes to a polite halt, and you step outside the engine to play with a combat or stealth sequence that serves as little more then a decorated hallway to the next non-interactive story beat. You do not feel Ellie and Joel’s relationship in the gameplay as either character, you are simply shown it by the game insisting with cutscenes (or, even worse, cutscenes that force you to hold forward that allow you to do nothing else interactive) that these two have a deep bond. 

There is a common axiom among writers of all mediums: Show, don’t tell. Don’t explain that two characters have a deep bond, show it with their actions. I believe the writers of these poor attempts at “cinematic” games are trying to get at this advice; they want to show with these cutscenes their story, not explain it in dialogue lain overtop gameplay. But these writers are ignoring a vital fact about their chosen medium; to a video game, interaction is as vital as the written word to a book. “Show, don’t tell” must be applied by showing in gameplay, not by telling the player in a prerendered clip, not by an abstract tracker displaying how happy your fictional girlfriend is with your choice of wall paint, but with interactions with the player that create a story. Ignoring the visceral power of creating a direct link between a player and the plot by turning the gameplay sections into conveyors towards “cinematic” moments displays a flagrant disregard for the medium you are working in, a loathing for it failing to be something it should never have been twisted towards in the first place. The way you make a ‘cinematic’ game was discovered in 1996 by Shinji Mikami: do something interesting with the camerawork, and use the gameplay and interactivity to give the feeling of being a film protagonist. It’s a far more successful strike at the label of cinematic than whatever the Game Awards will put up as their best narrative game this year, and you can bet on that.